|
Report of the seminar on land issues held
in Makamba
from 3rd of October to 8th October 2007
Summary Report
Detailed description of activities and tasks during project implementation
Preparation
It has not been easy for us to get access to the three old refugee camps
since there was a census going on in those camps. The census was being
conducted by UNHCR in conjunction with the Tanzanian Government. In this
census, refugees were to choose between:
1. being repatriated
2. getting a Tanzanian citizenship
3. being resettled in a third country
However, we were able to reach refugees via people who are residing in
those camps (co-ordinators) and we went to meet them outside refugee camps.
In Burundi, the preparation has not been easy either. First of all, we
met the three Governors who in turn introduced us to the 15 targeted commune
administrators. Those administrators introduced us to the occupants. In
the beginning, it has not been easy to convince the occupants to attend
the seminar/consultation. They were very much suspicious, as they could
not figure out what could be the outcome of the seminar but the tripartite
co-operation assured them.
The purpose of the project was to bring refugees and occupants of their
land to the same table to share their concerns and how to find possible
solutions.
-1-
|
Consultation/seminar
After tedious preparation, the time of the consultation arrived. It was
due to take place from 4th to 8th October 2007. The 15 refugee representatives
from the 3 old refugee camps: 5 from Mishamo, 5 from Katumba and 5 from
Ulyankulu arrived in Burundi on 3rd of October 2007. Participants to the
consultation included:
" 7 Rema Ministries officers (some of them were facilitators)
" 3 Governors of Provinces (Bururi, Makamba and Rutana).
" 15 Administrators of targeted Communes.
" 15 refugees from refugee camps
" 15 land occupants
" 5 people who accepted to share the lands they are occupying with
returnees. These people were brought in to share and give testimonies
and act as guinea- pig and this was a marvellous idea from the different
Governors of Provinces.
" 4 members of National Land Commission and other Properties
" 3 Bishops: bishop of the Anglican church, Makamba diocese, bishop
of EUSEBU church and bishop of Calvary Evangelical Assembly
" Minister of Information and Spokesperson of Burundi Government
" 1 member from Bureau Integre des Nations Unies au Burundi (BINUB)
" 2 Advisors of the Governor of Makamba
" 1 environmental police officer
" Many journalists
" One Advisor of the province of Rutana and member of National Land
Commission and other Properties
" Etc (many more people decided to attend without being invited by
either Rema or local administration but because they had some interests
in the issue at hand.)
-2-
|
Activities
The co-ordinator, Frederic Harerimana, introduced the consultation by
addressing the audience. He thanked the attendants and underlined the
scope, the objectives, aim and methodology of the consultation.
As the consultation took place in the premises of the Anglican Church,
Bishop Nyaboho Martin Blaise welcomed the visitors and wished them well
in the consultation. After the welcome address and reading of the word
of God by the same Bishop, he showed that the idea of property and land
was a crucial issue even in biblical times. He then invited the Governor
of Makamba to welcome the other Governors and administrators and any
participants to the workshop.
After the introduction and welcome, each Governor got an opportunity
to present the land problems in their respective provinces. The problems
look almost alike, apart from some specificity, in all those provinces
reason why participants to the seminar were drawn from those provinces.
Basically, refugees fled the country leaving their land behind. As they
delayed to come back, their lands were occupied either by their siblings
who never went into exile, or occupied by intruders, or redistributed
by the Government to other people. Now that refugees are intending to
come back, they wish to know what the Government will do for them as
most of them only know to dig land. As days went on each facilitator
took time to address the audience on the subject he has researched on
after which, group discussions were organised.
The land Commission member, Issa Ngendakumana and the team from Land
Commission and other Properties, thanked Rema Ministries to have organised
the seminar and ifa zivik to have availed the funds to make the consultation
a reality. Indeed, there were so many questions addressed to the team
by the refugees. The team got the opportunity to tell the refugees that
they should have a changed and flexible mind. After elaborating on the
problems, they clearly showed them that many things have changed since
they left and that there has been a population increase and growth leading
to scarcity of land. Most refugees thought that once they come back,
they would get back their land in its entirety, which is almost impossible.
The team however added that in case the Land Commission investigates
and finds that the occupant has got another piece of land in another
place, the latter has to relinquish the land to the initial owner.
The discussions we had were guided by the following topics:
" Nature of land conflicts in the province of Makamba and resolution
attempts
" Nature of land conflicts in the province of Rutana and attempts
of resolution
" Specificity of the land conflicts in the province of Bururi re
refugees of the year 1972 and administrative attempts in favour of reconciliation.
" Religious, ancestral and traditional concepts of refugees of
the year 1972 concerning the land problems and their repatriation.
" National land commission approaches in favour of reconciliation.
" Burundi law in regards of land: the provisions of the Home Affairs
Ministry.
Journalists interviewed refugees, land occupants and those who accepted
to share with returnees. The consultation was aired on the Burundi TV
network and different Media in order to inspire any other stakeholders
in the whole Burundi.
-3-
|
Achievement versus desired Goals
Our initial goal was to promote peaceful coexistence of the refugees returning
home and the present landowners, so as to aid faster and organised repatriation.
In order to achieve this goal, Land Commission members shed light on different
methodologies and strategies used to reconcile land owners and land occupants.
Participants found the seminar very important and timely as it addressed
their imminent felt needs. The three Governors attended the consultation/seminar
and made an expose to the audience on land problems in their respective
provinces to the astonishment of refugees who had never sat together with
the highest provincial authorities. This gave to the refugees a hope that
as the governors are aware of the problems they would intervene in solving
land problems hence avoid any chaotic disputes on land.
Effects of consultation
The Refugees were able to air their concerns as to why they have not yet
come back to Burundi and the major reason is that their lands are still
occupied.
Occupants aired their views as to why they continue to occupy refugees'
lands and asked to the Government to give them other alternatives.
Those land occupants, who accepted to share with returnees, were used
as guinea- pig to convince, indulge and stimulate other land occupiers
to do likewise when refugees come back.
After the seminar/consultation, some occupants vowed to go back and prepare
to vacate other people's lands even before repatriation.
Other occupants still vowed to sensitise and mobilise other lands' occupants
who did not attend the seminar to follow suit.
-4-
Measures of achievement
Bringing together 15 communal administrators, 3 Governors, members from
National land commission and bishops shows how the land issue problem
in Burundi is a crucial matter which needs crucial attention.
The presence of the journalists from National network Television and some
other Media proved that the issue of land is crucial and should not be
neglected if the Government is to avoid chaos.
The presence of the Minister for Information and Spokesperson for the
Government proves that the issue at hand was crucial to the Government.
Refugees requested to be compensated for the 35 years the occupants have
been exploiting their lands but they were clearly shown that due to circumstances
that led to this exploitation of the lands, it would be impossible to
compensate them for the following reasons:
" It would be difficult to calculate the amount of money they should
be compensated.
" The government is struggling with many other issues like repatriating
them and their goods
" There are internally displaced people who would also like to be
compensated as well.
" If they were compensated, it could create an imbalance and everybody
would wish to be compensated.
-5-
|